View Full Version: American Standards - Best Theme Night Ever?

realityisland >>American Idol 5 >>American Standards - Best Theme Night Ever?


<< Prev | Next >>

Matt- 04-20-2006
American Standards - Best Theme Night Ever?
I don't care how much the judges and Ryan loved this week's show, I thought it was one of the most boring ever. The songs pretty much put me to sleep. Why they kept going on about how great a week it was, I'll never know. I personally thought it was one of the worst this season.

idolfan- 04-20-2006

It was good in the sense that it was unpredictable about who would go home because several of them had very nice performances. It was not the best though and I have not heard critics giving it any acclaim like Ryan said. I also didn't see how good Katharine's was. I found it really boring, and lacking in personality. :roll:

pika- 04-20-2006

I agree with you about Katharine, idolfan. I don't see what everyone is raving about over her. I think she's boring, too. I think what was good about the Standards night was it was some of the best performances by the con-*test*-('")ants this season. The previous two weeks (at least) have been pretty bad but this time only Kellie really wrecked her song. The others did pretty good!

Matt- 04-20-2006
Re: Best Week Ever?
Am I the only one that thinks Kellie didn't screw up? I thought she did pretty good. As good as everyone else, I suppose. You're right, Pika. Everyone did pretty well this week, it might be why the judges and Ryan said it was the best week ever. It was still boring as heck, though. And I definitely wouldn't call it one of the best weeks of all five seasons.

idolfan- 04-21-2006
Re: Best Week Ever?
Am I the only one that thinks Kellie didn't screw up? Yes. You've been hypnotized by her looks. jk You're not the only one obviously because she was out of the bottom 3 which means she was in the top 4. :shock:

Her Grace- 04-21-2006

Bleck-bleck-bleck to Kellie the pickle! I cannot wait til she goes!!!!! Once her and Elliot are gone, things are gonna get raw!!!! I won't even really know who to root for, except I really really think the final two should no doubt be Paris and Chris.

idolfan- 04-21-2006

except I really really think the final two should no doubt be Paris and Chris. I knew I liked you!

Matt- 04-22-2006
Re: Kellie Pickler
You've been hypnotized by her looks. Eh, she's not really my type. Believe it or not, I actually like her because of her talet. I really do think she's good, I'm serious. And because y'all dislike her so much, I'm going to be using her as my avatar until she is eliminated. Ha! :grin:

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.